Public Forum Information

David Williams & Teniqua Williams (08/19/24)

“School Board, on May the 20th, 2024, I came before the school board on behalf of my daughter, [student’s name], who is being discriminated against by people Wylie ISD has in charge who are supposed to protect all students. I brought a matter to the attention advising that [Athletic Director] and [Wylie East Campus Athletic Coordinator] were denying her the right to a college signing day. Although she was a multi-sport athlete that played tennis, golf, basketball, participated in band, all while being in the top 10%. The board's response was that she didn't play golf for Wylie East her junior or senior year, and that's simply not true. In fact, I have pictures of her at the district golf tournaments in Wylie East uniforms her sophomore year and junior year. She is also featured in the 2024 yearbook playing golf with the team her senior year, quoted by the yearbook staff. So my question to this board is, what due diligence did you do to protect my daughters from yet another false allegation? 

I'm back again today to say that whatever effort that was put in was a failed attempt of as my daughter [student’s name] is now a victim of [Wylie ISD Athletic Director] and [Wylie East Campus Athletic Coordinator], [WEHS Tennis Coach] and [WEHS Tennis Coach]’s wrath. Their unrelentless pursuit of retaliation, bullying, and targeting of my daughters and family are created in an unsafe and hostile environment. On Friday, August 16th, 2024, two assistant principals, uh, came to tab [student’s name] tennis classroom, in Coach [name] and Coach [name’s] room, along with the rest of the class advised [student’s name] was there in the class, whether they proceeded to call her out of class and asked her to deliver a letter to her parents. When she came back to class, of course, students were curious and asking her questions on what it was about, why was she being called out, totally embarrassed and yet again, not protected. When I opened the letter from Mr. [Wylie East Campus Athletic Coordinator], it stated the following, ‘Mr. and Ms. Williams, [Wylie ISD Athletic Director] and I have tried multiple times to reach you beginning last spring to set up a meeting. I know you sent, I know he sent you another email last week, 8/05, followed by the phone call 8/08, where he left a message again, letting you know that we needed to meet. I have some concerns that I had needed to discuss with both of you regarding the Wylie East High School tennis program. After conversations with Dr. Spicer, the deputy superintendent and Amanda Lannan, assistant superintendent, we have decided that until such time that you set the meeting with me, [student’s name] will no longer be able to participate at Wylie East High School tennis team. The suspension will go in effect Monday, August 19th, 2024. It is my hope that you will contact, contact me using the information below.’ And how many of you will protect your children? How many of you will allow this to happen to your children? I can't do that... [time expired].” - Mr. David Williams 

“See, the last time we met with this group of folks that falsely accused my children of falsifying a doctor's note, then proceeded to call the doctor's office to verify the authenticity of the doctor's note. Crazy, right? These are adults, yet they're behaving as children. Pride and ego don't have any room to exist when children are involved. Seeking revenge on our children for us, being vocal advocates and protecting our children should never occur in the school district and simply is not the Wylie Way. The number one player on the tennis team being suspended because her parents didn't bow down to massa and come to a meeting. The same parents who attended the parent tennis meeting, along with all the other parents, the same parents who signed the required documents along with all the other parents, she's now being singled out. Although [Wylie ISD Athletic Director] did call and apologize for his action of accusing my kids of falsifying a doctor's note, he's yet to cease attacking my family. My question to the board and our elected representatives remain the same. What are you gonna do to ensure my daughters are protected from the wrath of these adults that are putting these places and abusing their power? 

I implore you to dig deeper, to figure out why my children are being abused. They are victims and they deserve equal treatment. That's what we thought was meant by the Wylie Way. When you go to sleep tonight, are you gonna worry about your kid going to school and being abused? Do you have to frantically stay awake at night and try to figure out what type of injustice your child will endure at the hands of egotistical adults? I do. And let me tell you, while you are peacefully sleeping, I'm up pondering and praying for God to keep my children safe. Yesterday, my daughter posted a note that said, if y'all know Jesus, why y'all act like that then? So I started thinking, yeah, that's a good question. It led me to Matthew 18:6, which reminds us if anyone causes one of these little ones, those who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for them to have a large millstone hung around their neck and be drowned in the depths of the sea. That's from the Bible. Woe, to the world that those things who will cause my children to stumble, such things must come with woe to the person who it comes from. So let me ask you, are you going to be a part of those who cause innocent children to stumble or are you going to do the right thing by God's chosen children? If I were you, I would choose the latter because have you seen those milestones? They're huge. You are the people that are elected by the representatives for a reason. I implore you to understand what that reason is as these kids say, you need to stand on business. You have an opportunity to protect these kids, and I pray that at least one of you has the courage to do so. Thank you.” -Mrs. Teniqua Williams

David Williams (05/20/24)

“Good evening, members of the board. My name is David Williams. I'm here to be the voice for my daughter, [student's name]. [Student's name] was ranked in the top 10% at Wylie East High School. She set a school record by placing first in district attendance twice in the last four years. She's a senior this year. In addition to that, she played varsity basketball this year. She also played golf for three years. I'm here today because tonight, [student's name] wasn't allowed the opportunity to sign on signing day as a student-athlete. She got a golf scholarship from Fisk University, where she will be attending starting in the fall. She should have been allowed to sign on signing day. We asked to see a policy, but it didn't exist, and was told it was a decision.

Never should leaders in the school district make decisions based on personal bias in retaliation. Each decision should be in the best interest of the student. To take away a child's hard work and accomplishments is simply unfair to the child and should not be in the hands of unreasonable egos. It is a shame that this is the example that Wylie ISD is showing their students. You know, it's very important, the examples we set for kids because we don't even realize when they're paying attention to us and when they're not paying attention to us. There have been numerous students that come up to me and my wife because we're always around and they say, “Hey, you know, we don't think that this was fair.” And so, this is just, you know, one thing that we wanted to relay to you, the board, but not just the board, but the school district and everyone who may have heard about the situation. As elected officials, which one of you will step in and be a voice for the students? This is not just about our daughter. This is about other students as well that may face this. Because we don't think anybody has faced this before in Wylie ISD or at Wylie East. What can you do to ensure that this doesn't happen again to the next kid? Out of the eight district champions, [student’s name] was one of those. Like Mr. Craighead said it is rare to get as many district champions as we've had. And it's kind of a detriment to the district to not realize that parents play a significant role in the kids actually succeeding and getting to the level where they can win the district championship. Thank you.” -David Williams

Lindsey Buerger (04/15/24)

“Hi, my name is Lindsey Buerger. These are my children, Eli, who is 12 and in seventh grade, and Emmeri, who is 11 and in fifth grade. They’re both homeschooled but both attended Smith Elementary through fourth grade and had many wonderful educational experiences there. My husband and I chose to homeschool our children beyond elementary for a number of reasons and both are thriving, but we are still big fans of the school district and the amazing educators here. Eli currently plays basketball for both the rec and competitive league. Emmeri is a dancer who participates on a competitive dance team. She’s an artist, a writer and has a love for acting and music. Both have maintained great relationships with many of their public school peers since they began homeschooling, and they would love to be able to expand their opportunities for sports and arts within their own community of Wylie during the UIL school seasons.
 

So, as a taxpaying resident of this district, I’m here today to ask you to support and opt-in by Wylie ISD to allow homeschooled students access to UIL extracurricular, academic and athletic activities. Due to the passage of Texas Bill 547 in 2021, homeschooled students are now allowed to participate in UIL-sanctioned, extracurricular activities. Texas House Bill 3708, which passed in 2023, ensures that school districts that opt to allow homeschool participation in UIL will now receive funding of $1,500 per student, per activity in which they participate. Not only is this a matter of personal importance to my family, but homeschool access to UIL activities is also extremely valuable to our district and the Wylie community for the following reasons -- Allowing homeschooled students to participate will increase the talent pool for both academic and athletic extracurricular activities. Increasing the talent pool will only lead to the further success of the district’s programs and the success of student teams. Allowing homeschooled students to participate will foster a stronger sense of community among the students, parents, and families within Wylie ISD. Extracurricular activities are often where communities bond. Bringing more people into that community will only make it more diverse and enrich the community bonds, representing the Wylie Way. Currently, there are already 37 other states dating back 50 years which allow homeschoolers access to extracurricular activities within public schools and now finally, Texas schools have the opportunity to catch up, and allowing homeschooled students access to participate will mean giving students living within this district both academic and athletic opportunities that they might not ever otherwise have, altering the course of their future. I do understand that this will take work on both the part of the homeschool parents, students, and the Wylie ISD educators and administrators to ease the transition for the schools. There are a number of other Texas school districts who have made this work over the last couple of years… [time expired]” -Lindsey Buerger

Michael Schwerin (02/26/24)

“Thank you, Dr. Day, school board members and administration. I’m coming up here actually in reference to a conversation that you and I had with Dr. Day after our last school board election. (And) one of the things that you promised to me, and I promised to hold you accountable for was that you would be more transparent in the budgeting process each year, and I’m coming up here tonight because unfortunately, I’ve not seen that transparency transpire so far even this year during the budgeting process. I know even in past years there have been multiple conversations, multiple presentations that we can see what’s happening within the budget and how things are happening, and this year has not been anything.

In fact, last month when during the presentation, not a single one of you board members asked a question about the budget process about what was happening, didn’t provide any kind of direction, as you are school board members, you’re fiscally responsible for our taxpayer dollars. And you should be asking those questions, and you should be providing the guidance, the overall guidance for the school district and for the administration on how they should be spending our taxpayer dollars. Tonight was another perfect example of a presentation that was put up here by Dr. Vinson, it was probably a great, great idea that we should all be supporting and be doing, but there probably is a price tag associated with that and there wasn’t a single question about what that cost would look like for us, and what that would affect our budgeting. As someone who works on a daily basis with people that are struggling to meet their daily needs with food, rent and utilities, I find it important that you guys consider those hundreds of families here in Wylie that are struggling like that, probably thousands of families in Wylie that are struggling with that.  And for many of them, they’re being priced out of their homes, they can’t afford food to put on their table or rent or utilities and they’re being forced out. In fact, I’ve had friends that have been forced out of Wylie ISD because they can’t afford the rent on their homes anymore and that falls strictly on the seven of you as board members. You have the fiscal responsibility to make sure that you’re keeping your tax rate lower and keeping fiscally and sound responsibility of our funds. I don’t think you’ve looked at anywhere you can cut expenses and I’m not saying that we need to cut everything, they’re probably things we can all agree on that we should be focusing on, whether special education, funding safety security, SROs, several other things that are in there with the disciplinary stuff that was discussed tonight.

There’s lots of great things that can be done, but then there are probably things that we can be cutting. I don’t think any of us have an organization or business that we don’t cut some things year after year that just are no longer fiscally responsible or fiscally manageable for us to do. That’s all we’re asking to do is to be mindful of that and look at ways you can cut and keep our taxes in line and keep our taxes lower. Thank you.” -Michael Schwerin

Jay Combs (01/22/24)

"Well, good evening, and thank you for having me. I’ll start by telling you something that you already know very well. The teachers, leadership and staff at Smith Elementary School are amazing. They are incredible educators, and for four years, they worked hard to provide the best learning experience possible to my son, to my wife and I’s son, and that’s not an easy task. You see he’s visually impaired. He reads, writes, does math via braille, only braille. He gets around by use of a mobility cane and that presents difficulties, but the Smith Elementary School is top-notch in how they dealt with that. However, the school board needs to hear about challenges as well as congratulations. You see, two years ago, the special education executive department decided to remove our son’s braille teacher and replace her with an out-of-state contractor doing teleteaching. If that sounds incredible, insane to you to teach a blind student via television, that’s because it is. It’s like teaching a deaf student over the telephone. And, my wife and I, of course, objected to that and the school district went to the lengths of actually hiring a lawyer who spent an entire day at the meeting with my wife and I – thousands of these taxpayers' dollars were spent to defend this teleteacher.

Ultimately, the school relented, and they hired an emergency certified teacher who had not even completed her course studies in braille yet and never taught an academic braille student. Unfortunately, my wife and I had to make the heartbreaking decision that the needs of our son required us to resort to schooling for our son privately so we can have access to teachers who are experienced and could meet his needs. Last year, while he was still a student in this school district, he competed on behalf of this very school district in an event called the Braille Challenge. It’s kind of like the National Spelling Bee, but it’s all in braille. To the braille students, it’s every bit as important as the National Spelling Bee. He won that event at Region 10 and his score was high enough that he was called on to represent the state of Texas–the entire state of Texas–in an international competition at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. In fact, he was one of the top 10 students in the world last year. He wasn’t recognized by this board, but he was one of the top 10 students in the world, and he represented the state of Texas with pride. At the end of the regionals, he received three things…a backpack, a braille monopoly game, and he was so proud to receive those, but he also received a braille printer. It’s called an embosser, and after the conclusion of that event, his teacher told us that they’d keep the embosser at the school to use them, and we of course agreed, but when we made the heartbreaking decision to remove [student] from the school district… [time expired]" -Jay Combs

We appreciate Mr. Combs taking the time to address the school board. Board members and district leadership were concerned and saddened to hear about the family’s experience. Our deputy superintendent has been in contact with the family and has discussed each of the situations mentioned in Mr. Combs’ remarks to the Board. We are grateful for the conversations we’ve had with Mr. Combs, and we are committed to working with the family regarding their needs and what they believe is best for their child.

Aleksandra Rolfson (08/21/23)

“Good evening, y'all. I'm here to speak about the bond, but I do need to address a quick note. I was surprised to have Wylie ISD employee sign me up to speak tonight. I had to provide my ID. Board operating procedure says a person who is wishing to address the board shall sign up prior to the beginning of the meeting on the day of the meeting. The signup sheet for citizen comments will be available at the meeting location. Each citizen should sign up personally. It says nothing in there about providing ID or anything else. Just a quick note.

Now about the bond. It's a nearly $300 million bond that's being proposed. My question to ISD and to the board of trustees is, if this $298 million bond is passed and new schools are built, where would funding for new expenses come from? New expenses such as teacher salaries, utilities, maintenance, et cetera? From my understanding, this bond cannot be used for those things. It has to come from an operating budget. We all know where the operating budget comes from. And even though this bond may not raise taxes right now, it more than likely will raise this operating budget for all these new expenses.

I would appreciate it if you guys would answer that or at least consider answering it. Thank you.” -Aleksandra Rolfson

Michael Schwerin (08/21/23)

“Again, I would like to actually reiterate Aleksandra's comments as I start my speech as well too, is that if you are going to change the protocol, a notice would be great and helpful for that for people that are there. I mean, thankfully I had my ID on me, but some people may not carry their ID or may be in their car and may not have it with them here and leave it at their house. And so just a simple email or notification, like several other districts do when they change their protocol, would be helpful for transparency purposes, as well too.

The first thing I'd like to also talk about is the tax rate. It's interesting that for years we've been told that there's no way we can ever do the no new revenue rate here in Wylie ISD. It's just not possible. But then come to hear the news last week that I believe, if I was reading the numbers correctly, from Frisco ISD, is that they actually were able to pass a rate that was below the no new revenue rate for some reason. Didn't have any conversation about losing state funding or being penalized from the state, which is what we've been told is the issue here. And it's interesting that Frisco is the one district that we're chasing up there on our school accountability ratings, and they're yet able to do that.

So again, I'd reiterate the ability for us to be bold as our new logo and our new information is, and look at why we can't do that and why we can't look at keeping the rate under the no new revenue rate. If they're able to do it, then it's obviously something that can be done. So let's start looking at that.

Secondly, with the bond, I would also like to talk as a member of the Facilities Master Plan Committee that met over the last [inaudible 00:03:41], I think it's important that I speak up for the several committee members that were speaking last week at the meeting and brought up our concerns about the feasibility and just the look of having a $300 million bond with a single question during our current economic situation that we're in. I think several of us asked, do we really want that all in one question? Why can't it be broken out into several questions? I'm not saying that we don't need some of the items on there. I think several of the items are needed and are very important, but it's also a matter of in the current economic situation that we're in what's actually needed and required for us to do our business, and what is nice to have that could be pushed off and waited and not put more burden on our taxpayers.

And one example of that was the elementary school. We find out last week that they're still looking at three different options for the elementary school rather than looking at the one. So if we don't even know what we're going to go with for that elementary school, why are we putting that in the bond right away? And when we don't know, there's three or four different options that we're still looking at for how we might configure that elementary school.

Another interesting thing was breaking it out into several questions because that was what the county is doing. The county is doing a $600 million bond. They have it in several different propositions. Why can't we do that same thing?

So thank you for your time and I just hope that you'll consider looking at being empathetic to our community.” -Michael Schwerin

Dawn Shallow (08/21/23)

“First of all, I'd like to look at each one of you as I read this. I'm here tonight to express my grievance with Wylie ISD. You have violated my protected First Amendment right. I hereby put you on notice that you have violated my First Amendment right, which is free from retaliation. On June 19th, during your last school board meeting, I used my First Amendment right to speak to the school board meeting and to object to the high tax rate. And as it pains me right now and hurts me to repeat your words, but these are your retaliation words to me on your public government site.

‘Wylie ISD is appalled and disheartened that Mrs. Dawn Shallow compared Wylie ISD taxpayers to the atrocity of slavery’ ... it goes on. But you also go on to say, ‘Wylie ISD sincerely apologizes to any individual who may have been hurt or offended by the insensitive comments made.’ 

That's my right, my free speech that you're speaking of. What was my sin? What demanded such public shaming and retaliation? Using my First Amendment right to come on the night that you're discussing Wylie taxes, objecting to the tax rate and stating that myself and fellow taxpayers are financial slaves to this Wylie ISD budget.

Regardless of how you interpret my words, it is my protected First Amendment right. We speakers follow your rules. Don't name names, don't call out people, but your response on your public website is personal, emotional, and inappropriate.

Before I lose my time, I want to make sure I let you know that I have been harmed by your retaliatory response to my protected First Amendment rights and ask for a written apology, a written public apology on the same school board public forum comments website, and retraction of your unconstitutional retaliatory response. There was a court hearing. I see your lawyers are here today. It is case number 122-CV448DAE on June 26th of this year, that Judge David Allen Ezra stated in his order on a Round Rock ISD retaliation against a person's First Amendment right.

The Judge states page 20, section E., First Amendment Retaliation. As a general rule, the First Amendment prohibits government officials from subjecting an individual to retaliatory actions for engaging in protected speech. A First Amendment of Retaliation claim requires that a plaintiff show, one, he was engaged in constitutional protected speech. Two, the defendant's actions- [time expired]” -Dawn Shallow

Jeffrey Keech (08/21/23)

“Bonds. I looked through the Master Facilities Planning Committee meeting notes, and I am not convinced the school district needs any additional schools. I looked at the campus facilities' handout from the March MFP meeting, the 17 elementary, middle, and junior high schools were all listed, along with their projected percentage of capacity in the 2027/28 school year. There were two schools, Akin and Burnett, were listed as being over a 100% capacity. Watkins was listed at 100% and the other 14 schools were all listed at below a hundred percent capacity. Five of those 14 schools are listed at below 90% of capacity. I believe that the school capacity district-wide is projected to be 92% in 2028. And I think a little bit of rezoning can handle any capacity issue at one or two schools.

Also in the March meeting slides was a slide highlighting the 2019 to 2022 three-year enrollment change for ISDs in this area. Wylie ISD increased by 10% and some of the high-growth districts to the east, such as Princeton or Community, increased by about 40%. However, enrollment in the more developed districts declined. Plano declined by 7%. Garland declined by 4%. Richardson declined by 4%. McKinney declined by 5%, and Allen declined by about .5%.

So the 10-year Wylie ISD student population projection from the master facility planning notes is projected to grow by 16% compared to 41% growth in the prior 10 years. So all of this is a strong indication to me that soon the student population here will plateau and then it will be stable or slightly decline.

And so just to close, to put this proposed bond initiative into perspective, the current pre-K to 12th grade student population is approximately 18,866 students, is projected to grow by between 1,523 and 2,318 students in the next five years, with the average projection being a growth of 1,877 students. Again, that's from the Master Facilities Planning notes. So the bond proposal being discussed is for $298 million dollars. So using the average growth projection of 1,877 new students, that equates to a cost of $156,738 for each new student. And I just ask if any of my numbers are not correct, can you please use the public forum to correct those for me? But anyway, thank you very much for your time.” -Jeffrey Keech

Michael Schwerin (06/19/23) - Public Hearing

“First of all, I'd like to say that I do understand this is a tough budget year. I think everyone in the audience and every one of the taxpayers are dealing with the inflationary issues that we're struggling with. But I also think that I was hoping that you all would take a more conservative approach. You all have said many times that you are conservatives and oftentimes, I've been told you're much more conservative than I am. But when you don't look at actually asking the staff to make cuts in areas that they can, I understand that there's lots of instructional areas that should be off limits, and there's certain other areas that are, and I do applaud you for actually increasing the special education budget. Because I actually remember about 10 months ago, I came here and asked about that, and I was told very inconsiderately that you guys were spending way more than you needed to and everything was fine. All the while you were actually finding out that you were needing to spend more and have more in the special education budget, which is what I knew was happening after talking to teachers and to parents within the district.

But then at the same time, you can look at other areas to cut. I run an organization, I have to do that all the time. I have to look at ways when I'm adding in mandatory requirements, to make increases to my health insurance costs and to other additional costs due to inflation. I look at other areas so that I can balance that out and where I can look at making cuts. And when you look at the budget and you have an increase of over a million dollars and you look at the administrative and then just leadership salary positions, that becomes a little bit frightening in there that we're looking at those kinds of increases, when there, which probably are not necessarily all due to inflationary issues.

And then, at the same time when you're talking about the security issues and then you look at the budget and the budget in the safety and security is actually flat, is a little bit concerning as well to me, that we should be looking at that. And in this day and age, are we really wanting to keep leaving that flat? Again, these are no questions that I haven't heard from any of you all. I mean I was told a year ago, during last election that we were going to have a much more transparent budget cycle, but I think it's actually been a little less transparent because there's been less questions from you all seven, asking where the money is going, where can we cut, where can we look at making cuts? That's what a conservative elected official does, who's a good steward of our dollars, looks at making those cuts.

And yes, we might be doing a balanced budget, but maybe the conservative way is looking at doing a deficit budget where we spend down some of the 77 million dollars that we have in our cash reserve. And maybe this is the time, this is a rainy day. It's a really bad year economically for everybody, so maybe we need to look at making that kind of cut. But, there's not been any kind of that kind of discussion by the seven of you all and that's what makes me very disappointed. Thank you.” -Michael Schwerin

Dawn Shallow (06/19/23) - Public Hearing

“Hello and Happy Juneteenth Day. This date represents the end of slavery. That's a wonderful concept for everyone except for Wylie ISD taxpayers, because we are slaves to the Wylie ISD finance department, superintendent and school board. In economic downtimes such as this, parents, students, taxpayers are struggling to pay basic necessities. Yet our school district thinks it's a good idea to increase our taxes so that they can get a piece of the pie, of our overinflated property values.

So, I'd like to ask some questions. Why can't you vote for a no-new-revenue rate? The no-new-revenue rate is 1.27%. It's simply 0.09% less than what the finance guys have proposed. Why can't you make cuts to travel lunches, further education, in these economic hard times? Just because you can milk the taxpayers and increase our taxes doesn't mean you should.

Every year our school board gives the district an open checkbook, which shouldn't happen, especially in these times. I ask you to send the budget back and ask the finance department to use the no-new-revenue rate of 1.27, which is the no-new-revenue rate, it's just like what the City of Wylie can do, then our district should be able to do. If you can't do that, I ask you to send the budget back and ask them to cut 10%. If you can't do that, I ask you to send the budget back and ask them to cut another 5%. I'll have more to say about the budget during the public forum. Thank you.” -Dawn Shallow

Luca Pareti (06/19/23) - Public Hearing

I'm new to this city, and I see a unique opportunity in this city for the community and Wylie ISD to collaborate and start a new approach. I think that the idea that Wylie ISD feels undermined if they stop spending or if they do less, and vice versa, some citizens are mad, when they see their money misspent. We can change it because the property values doubled in the last five years. This gives a unique opportunity to this school district to have an enormous amount of money, without really increasing or maintaining the same rates. Technically we could cut the rates at 50%, with adjusted inflation, and have the same income.

Now of course, all the expenses are going up every year. This year particularly, we have high inflation. But I think if we open our minds and we start thinking about new ways to be efficient, there are going to be areas like special education, where I think we all agree, we want to put some more money.

But, I'm sure if we take the same effort that we put into what can we do more, where we can spend money? If we apply the same energy to where we can cut money, we are going to find ways where we are going to be happy. We are going to be able to keep the spend low and at the same time, Wylie ISD is going to be productive, efficient, and we're not going to lower in the quality of the education. I think it takes an effort from all of us to give you feedback and from all of you to give us a feedback, have an open discussion. And I think if we reduce the friction and do it more friendly, I think we can really find a solution for this and we're all going to benefit from it. I think transparency, like Michael said, I think it's the key. If there is going to be transparency, everyone can have honest feedback, and if we take the time to go back and forth and put it together, I think we're going to succeed in making progress.

This is going to be a tough year. We don't know what's going to happen over the next couple of years. A lot of people are looking at private school, homeschooling. At some point, the numbers may start going down, may start slowing down. And I think that needs to be put into consideration. I think if you start thinking about this now, we're going to be in a good position when maybe, there's going to be school vouchers, maybe there's going to be major changes in the scenery. And I just wanted to raise those points because I think it's the right time now to think about how we can cut so we can be efficient in the next short future. That's all.” -Luca Pareti

Dawn Shallow (06/19/23) - Public Forum

“OK, so I couldn't get this all in one speech, so I broke it into two. I'm speaking tonight, not so much for the school board, because you all don't listen to taxpayers. First of all, give me 10 things that you have voted no on in the last five years, 10 years. Have you ever voted no? You don't listen to us. So maybe in the board notes you can tell us 10 things that you voted no on.

I'm speaking tonight mostly for my fellow Wylie and Murphy Taxpayers. The school district gets a near-maximum school tax rate on our homes. The maximum they can charge is a rate of 1.3645. They threw us a bone this year and are proposing a rate of 1.3622. That's a 0.0023 difference. In other words, we taxpayers will see another increase to our tax rates of approximately $400 for each homeowner. They show us a lower rate because it's pleasing to your eyes. But what actually happens is that your overinflated property taxes are here, their rate comes down here, they're still getting multi-million dollar increases. Wylie ISD is taking advantage of the uninformed, those who are too intimidated to speak at these meetings to you because of the retribution that you give, and you're taking advantage of the taxpayer's overall good nature.

Taxpayers, Wylie ISD lies to you about the process. If you listened carefully tonight, they set the tax rate. And they said our property values could go up, could go down, and that's going to alter the tax rate. But did you hear them once say that their budget is going to alter or fluctuate? No. Their budget is set in stone, they're not willing to budge and they base it on our overinflated property taxes. Like I say to my kids, do you want it or do you need it? Even listening to Ms. Spicer just now, there are all these things that people want that we don't need, especially in a down economy, just as we have now.

To add salt to the tax wound, these taxes aren't enough for them. They’ve already had plans in the works to ask voters to approve a multimillion-dollar bond package. Stay tuned for that. They want a new football field, more tennis courts and new furniture in an economic downturn. Friends, these people are not our protectors. They protect the school, they protect the teachers, they protect the administration. They don't protect parents and taxpayers. I'd like to know who's guarding the hen house? Because I see the foxes are. Thank you.” -Dawn Shallow

Randi Jackson (06/19/23) - Public Forum

“Good evening. We have a crisis in this country. It is not new. It's been going on for generations now. And the evidence of this crisis can be seen from the federal government all the way down to our local school boards. We have gotten into the habit of not living within our means. My household would fall under the category of economically disadvantaged, that 28.1%, this is last year's statistics that I'm going off of, of students that make up that portion of the district. This is a letter from my landlord that we got last week notifying me that because of property taxes, my rent's going up $300 starting next month. $2,500 a month for under 1100 square feet.

I am not alone in this. Renters, those of us who make up the majority of the economically disadvantaged, are being priced out of this district. If we can't buckle down and find a way to live and work within our means, we're doing the children we are here for a massive disservice. If we as a country, not just here in Wylie, but this is where we have the most impact locally, if we don't decide to bite the bullet and suffer a little bit now, we are doing our children a massive disservice and dooming them to suffer even more later.

Last year, Trustee Leggett asked, Assistant Superintendent of Finance and Operations, Mr. Roderick, how much we would lose if we adopted a no-new-revenue tax rate because it was right prior to an election, and that was one of the things that was being harped on. The answer was approximately $12 million, and that does sound like a lot, but considering the total budget of $181 million for general funds, that would bring us to $169 million from last year's numbers. This year, I'm not sure how that would be adjusted based on the new revenue rates and all that stuff because you guys hire people who are a lot more knowledgeable and better at that stuff to know those things.

All those aspects of the district are important, where you're talking about athletics, where you're talking about CTE, all of those things. But I can tell you that I'm not the only one getting priced out of Wylie. And if it affected you personally, you might give more weight to these warnings that we've been giving you. We absolutely want the best for our students in Wylie, but not at the expense of the less fortunate in Wylie. Real quick, fun fact. Did you know there are 31 million people living in Texas and the governor makes $153,000? There are 70,000 people in Wylie, and the superintendent makes over $280,000. Thank you.” -Randi Jackson

Dubravko Vukmirovic (05/15/23)

“Greetings, thank you so much for this opportunity. I want to be professional here. I had a son who was in middle school and now is in high school. I have 20 years in cybersecurity, holding architectural and management roles. It's very short. Wylie ISD doesn't have web filtering solutions for YouTube, games, or games on other non-game websites, including pornography. The ISD doesn't have any solution to prevent kids from that kind of dopamine drug in schools. A teacher came to me and said, "Your son is on YouTube for four hours across five teachers while in class." But I'm really asking myself, who is allowing this at school? The teacher says that they don't have time for this and, basically, I'm coming here to say that you have the power to prevent allowing any dealing of these dopamine drugs to our students. And then teachers punishing students because they cannot focus. You need to seriously look at this as a drug and look at who is sharing these drugs, allowing the drugs, et cetera.

Here's the solution, Blue Coat Proxy enterprise web filtering in your schools that will filter words on websites, not just one website name. Block YouTube. Another solution is to block YouTube and instead use myvrspot.com. Your teachers already have that, but it's always easier just to send a YouTube link, which now you have to enable the whole YouTube. Please follow up on these action items. In the world, in PISA, China is leading in the number one place while the USA is in the 13th place. So there we still have.

The second subject I want to address is physical education. As they chose a few sports players over the majority, children's obesity level in developed countries are three to 10%, and in Texas it's 46%, 15 times higher. The children in middle and high school get a hundred percent score 'already' only showing up. PE teachers are not responding to complaints and emails. Nobody tests children in a middle and high school for six pull-ups, 50 sit-ups, eight shuttle runs, seven feet long jumps, 50-yard dash, 600-yard run, a rope climb, and a one-mile, run for eight minutes and 23 seconds. Solution – implement APFT mandatory requirements for PE teachers, including like that. China is again leading. The United States had this in 1970 and then it kind of died down. So three minutes. [time expired].” -Dubravko Vukmirovic

Michael Schwerin (04/17/23)

“Good evening. I come up here speaking as a concerned parent who's not afraid to speak up and get up and talk to speak to you tonight. And I would hope that you would consider and realize over the last year how the number of parents that are up here speaking is actually decreasing. And I think Jill alluded to a little bit of that concern. That I'm not afraid to get up here and speak, but I am speaking for those that are afraid. Many have reached out to me via phone, email, and text, that are afraid to speak because of the attacks by district personnel and the gaslighting that we're receiving. It's just inappropriate for you to be spending taxpayer dollars on that kind of activities and attacking parents in Wylie ISD. And again, the way you do that with the public forum, with the forum comments using district resources on a district website is inappropriate and borderline illegal.

So why are they coming to us? I think that's something that all seven of you should be asking. They're coming to us, those of us that lost an election, that they're actually willing and hearing an open ear and a comforting ear and someone that's willing to stand up and speak for them, rather than going to the seven people that are elected to represent them. That should be really concerning to all of you and to the administration.

The administration chooses to gaslight, deflect, or attack parents that just bring up simple questions, and then community members as well, too, who aren't even students. And referring because we don't have students in this specific school that we don't have any rights to bring up any questions or comments about that, which is just incorrect.

This is a simple example of what happened recently in April with a trans substitute teacher that was teaching at Akin and Draper and at least one other school that I've been told by parents. Without any kind of confirmation and discussion to parents ahead of time or to district personnel, principals onsite. And when parents did reach out and ask about information, they received nothing. 'We're working on it. We're looking into it.' No more comments for three weeks. Why? Why are we not talking to our parents and answering questions and providing information? When you have a teacher, a substitute teacher, a trans substitute teacher that shows up and reads a story, that gets really concerning to a lot of parents in Wylie ISD. As a Christian community, a conservative community that I know all seven of you have talked about that we are, that should be concerning to all seven of you as well.

We're here, we're listening, we're not going away. We are on your side. I've said this multiple times in the two years I've been coming up here and speaking, that we wanna be here, we wanna be working with you, but when you attack us personally and professionally, that is a problem. And that's why no one is coming to you and no one's calling you and asking you directly. And they're coming to us 'cause we're willing to listen and have those conversations and then stand up here and take the arrows that are coming to us. Thank you.” -Michael Schwerin

Jill Palmer (04/17/23)

“Good evening. I'd like to begin by addressing the extremely hyperaggressive and frankly very hostile tone of accusation from the March forum response of me spreading misinformation.

It seems the author and those of you collectively approving those notes for comment are wanting to play in the game of Petty Polly. Well, I play that game pretty well myself. I just sent you an email. That email, do as you wish with the information. I have provided just one sliver of the misinformation that I have proven facts for. I really do not appreciate the aggressive and hostile attack on my integrity, ‘Spreading false information,’ is in fact defamation of my character.

Furthermore, in the same email that you received, you will find a written, respectful request at the advice of my own white-collar suit counsel. Yes, I have access to my own, mine are just way better dressed. They have advised that not only a written but a verbal request here for all of you to hear, I request that my family, let alone my children, will not be used in your comments. This is why. Because the actions of the supporters of the last election are completely questionable and I do not trust their mental health. And down the road, what if a rogue teacher wants to retaliate on my child. So, let's tone down the aggression because that is the reason why parents are scared and not wanting to come up and speak here.

Third, I want to respect the comments from last October, so I've been waiting 'til now. We have one month to the end of school, so I would love a recap as well as the stakeholders of the DEI committee of everything that's been actioned. What went well, what didn't, and what are the plans for the next year? What's going on there?

Ooh, I have plenty of time. So I'm gonna leave us with this and this is actually a closing more for Virdie and Mike 'cause I know you're new in your roles. I encourage you to start asking more questions. Both of you in your announcements for running for your seats, you basically had the same tone. You were making a commitment to continue on the vision of this leadership. Start asking questions, because currently, the vision is taking the rights away from the parents based on the influx of emails and messages I received of the parental rights being taken away of when and where their parents are able to engage their child in political and social conversation. That is not okay. Start asking questions because that is your legacy in the seats you hold. Thanks.” -Jill Palmer

Jeffrey Keech (04/17/23)

“Hello. School choice legislation was mentioned at the last school board meeting and one of the statements I heard was something along the lines of school choice opportunities that were debated in the Texas legislature would cost each ISD about $7,000 for every student that takes advantage of any of these school choice programs. So, this district here, spends, in '22-'23 spent $12,500 per student, and the statewide average is around $14,000 per student. So Senate Bill 8, which is probably the best known of the school choice bills that were debated in the statehouse that would fund an $8,000 education saving account for every parent who opts their child out of the public schools.

So, I assume that a school district that spends $14,000 per student educating, actually spends the $14,000 on the education of that child and that if the child were to withdraw from that school district, the total expenses for education for that district would decrease by $14,000. And not on a one-by-one basis, but if you take out 10 kids, I imagine the cost goes down by approximately $140,000. What else would the money be spent on if it's not spent on educating the students there? So, now, very basic math tells me that 14,000 minus 8,000 is 6,000. And so the state is actually saving $6,000 in education expenses for every child that opts out of the school district.

Furthermore, I think we can all agree that no one knows the needs of a child better than the parents. No one cares more for that child than their parents. And that parents would not take on the additional expense and commitment of a private or a charter school if the education for their child was worse at that school. The overall education experience provided for the child is- is gonna be at least as good and possibly better for each child that opts out of a public school.

So, the board's summary notes that are emailed after every one of these meetings, you addressed select comments from public forum speakers. And I would just like to ask if my math is incorrect or my belief that parents know the needs of their children best, if that's wrong, please take advantage of your summary notes and explain why my math isn't correct or why I'm wrong about the parents knowing best for their children.

It seems to me that if a parent finds a better educational opportunity for their children and the taxpayers of the state save $6,000 in the process, we should all be happy with that outcome. And it was disappointing to hear criticism of school choice programs at the last meeting here. And I just want to say that school choice initiatives place parents at the center of their children's education, it returns decision-making to the families, and I do think we should all remember that it’s always about the kids. Thanks very much.” -Jeff Keech

Shannon Ayres (04/17/23)

“Good evening. My name is Shannon Ayres and I am the Collin County Education Division Lead for Citizens Defending Freedom or CDF. I'm here regarding the recent proposed rule change to Title IX, that broadens its language to include sexual orientation and gender identity. This undermines federal law and the legislative authority of the United States Congress. While some organizations have followed the misleading guidance of the Department of Education's 2021 Notice of Interpretation, following President Biden's Executive Order on the Supreme Court ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County. Both have been significantly misinterpreted as it was made clear by the court that the latter was a Title VII issue that did not apply to Title IX or any other law.

The Supreme Court in Bostock emphasized that sex-based employment discrimination consisted was consistent with Title VII, but it was not. It was unconstitutional but explicitly refrained from applying their ruling to Title IX. As such, this renders the Department of Educations's NOI and the Executive Order null because it expressly contradicts Supreme Court precedent. If this wasn't enough, there have been a handful of cases further demonstrating the inapplicability of the Bostock ruling to Title IX issues. This includes a recent ruling out of a federal district court issuing a preliminary injunction barring the execution of the Biden Administration's NOI and Executive Order from taking effect in 20 states, including Arkansas and Oklahoma. Separately, a federal district court in Texas affirmed that sexual orientation and gender identity are not protected categories because Title IX must be read in the original context in which it was drafted in 1972, where sex was understood to be biological and binary. A federal appellate court covering Florida, Georgia, and Alabama jurisdictions also found this to be true, ruling that a local school board's bathroom policy did not violate Title IX because Title IX conforms to an understanding of sex consistent with the societal understanding of sex at the time of its drafting. Beyond this, applying any directive that neither conforms to these recent rulings nor takes into consideration the necessity of receiving Congressional approval before making a change to federal law is itself an unconstitutional act.

In Bostock v. Clayton, the Supreme Court stated the people's representatives are the ones who must amend Title IX, thereby making it unlawful for non-congressional officials, including school board members, to assume changes to Title IX in the absence of approval to amend it, a power reserved exclusively by Congress. I would ask that you consider this information before acting on the coercive tactics by organizations intentionally misapplying Title IX to push a political agenda. A serious consequence of this misapplication includes the erosion of student privacy stemming from the rights of students to use sex-separated facilities and to participate in sex-separated sporting activities. One final note. This rule change is currently open for public comment in the federal register until May 15. Due to the federalism implications of this rule change, they are encouraging state and local elected officials like yourselves to review and provide comments. [time expired]” -Shannon Ayres

Jill Palmer (03/20/23)

“Good evening you guys. I know it's been a couple of months. Mom duties and Monday's activities, so I haven't been here. But for some of you, the voices in your head, no, you haven't gotten rid of me just yet. I want to start to reiterate in December when I said the work starts now to try and figure out how we can keep moving forward to engage the community. I want to just bring tonight some reminders. The first reminder I want to reference, Dr. Day, when you talked to the PTA forum last October, you confessed that the board needs to do a better job communicating to the district, to community, to parents, to staff, what it means, what's going into the budget… Actually, the NNR is on the consent agenda, well you took it off the consent, it’s on the agenda. And I love that you’re expanding on it but what more can we do?

We always like to reference other school districts and mimic whatever decision [inaudible] to make. Plano ISD actually had town halls at the high schools and they were able to bring subject matters one or two that were going to be discussed on those evenings. So I think that's something that we can kind of try and figure out in our district because we haven't had that avenue. And so in order to get more money and more capital from us, I think we also need to have more information and not just a presentation, which is really hard to follow and you know no one is going to go online and listen to it. So let's just be real.

Reminder number two, your campaigns touted for all children, all students, right? You even used our taxpayer money to remind us that it's not all about education. It's about the character. Support of our students, our community, and our staff. So I kind of want to know where is support for our students that don't make this district look great, who don't support the ratings, the ones who are battling anxiety and depression every single day, who are dealing with the escalated fights happening at the highs, dealing with the perverse sexual behavior happening in the bathrooms, the vaping.

And the most tragic I've actually just confirmed two weeks ago, the five children who have taken their lives, and that's all that I know of. And when a concerned parent came to this district to figure out how to bring awareness, the district responded, ‘We don't want any negative awareness to our destination district.’ The irony of that with that answer. So is it really for all kids or is it for only the kids that make us look good? If we're going to support all kids, then show up.

The last reminder, the groomer teacher that resigned, he's still active at the State Board of Education, so whoever is in charge of getting that alerted and red-flagged where he doesn't have any further access to children, that needs to happen. Thanks.” - Jill Palmer

Michael Schwerin (03/20/23)

“Thank you. I'm here to speak again as a parent of the district and as a former candidate who talks to thousands and thousands of parents and taxpayers throughout the district. And again, I heard over the last 12 months, a lot I've heard about is, ‘It's all about the kids. All about the kids. All we care about is the kids.’ But then I come to the school board meetings and I start hearing more focus on ratings and how ratings and what the ratings are rather than actually what's happening within the classroom. Last month was a perfect example where we're concerned more about the fact that we might lose our ‘A’ rating than actually what's being taught to our students, and focusing more on college readiness versus career readiness in other areas.

And as a parent of a student who actually a couple of years ago came home crying because she decided that she might not want to go to college. She might want to just look at going directly into her career who was by staff, teachers, and students made ostracized and made to feel belittled because she decided she might not want to go to college right away. This is a pretty much straight-A, GT student who made this decision, who we support in that position who was ostracized. So I'm concerned about that. And then when we come up tonight and we start talking about the school voucher system and how that's going to hurt us, again, it's because you're saying they don't have accountability, but it's because people that are leaving this district, because they leave because of the school of vouchers, because of what the kids are being taught in their other districts, in their other schools and not being taught here or being exposed to here in Wylie ISD that they're not being exposed to in those other districts.

Things like books that we've heard about a lot about. And I was actually really alarmed to actually have a parent who happened to go to the Boots and Barbecue gala who showed me a picture of several pages of a book that was actually removed from the libraries here in Wylie ISD, the Boy Next Door because it was obscene and vulgar and was sitting on their table. And I don't know how many others had that happen, but that is alarming and I still don't understand what happened. As someone that's a fundraiser and does fundraising for a living and does events, I know it's difficult and there's a lot of things, the moving parts in there, but that's something that I would not have missed and I would've been paying attention to because it's been something that we've been talking about for the last 12 months or more here in Wylie ISD.

And then we come today's meeting as well too and I'm alarmed the fact that... As you said, Dr. Day, we are going to focus on being more transparent and more open, but then we spent all tonight we talked about was hearing about millions and millions and millions of dollars that you're asking us to spend. Not a single discussion about cutting budget or where we can cut expenses to make up for those needed increases in special education and other areas that I agree with, we need to do, but they also need to be looked at other areas that we can cut. That's how a true leader works and how a true leader that listens to the taxpayers who are concerned about the budget and concerned about the growing tax burden. Not blaming the state for putting more erroneous unbudgeted things to it, but actually figure out how we can make that work.” - Michael Schwerin

Board Reports, CCMR Report, and Vouchers

Wylie ISD provides the Board of Trustees with information reports about matters that affect the district. This includes but is not limited to reports about the budget, accountability and more. It appears that Mr. Michael Schwerin did not understand the Feb. 27, 2023, information report about the Texas Education Agency’s proposed changes to accountability for College, Career and Military Readiness (CCMR). The proposed changes diminish the work school districts are doing to prepare students for life beyond high school. Instead, the TEA is placing a heavier emphasis on:

• student persistence in college (whether students continue past the first year of college), and 

• irrelevant industry-based certifications (TEA is ‘sunsetting’ important certifications such as OSHA for student achievement indicators - see 2019-22 list vs. 2022-24 list on the TEA's industry-based certification list webpage.

Our goal as a school district is to provide educational experiences that will allow our students to thrive no matter what path they take. Not every student will attend college, and that is perfectly OK. We need to graduate workforce-ready young people who will help our country flourish and are passionate about their work. Wylie ISD and other public school districts should not be punished for these efforts.

Vouchers or ‘Education Savings Accounts’ is a hot topic in the 88th Legislature and would have a significant impact on public schools, including Wylie ISD. It is vital that we have conversations and discussions about matters that affect our district. We stand by our stance in opposing a school voucher system/Education Savings Account.

Boots ‘N Barbecue Gala

It is disappointing that Mr. Schwerin did not reach out to the Wylie ISD Education Foundation to learn more about the decorations. In fact, WEF had signage at the event that stated, “Decor brought to you by nearby libraries and friends. Books used for decorations were provided at no cost by local and regional libraries and were slated to be destroyed or recycled. They are for decoration purposes only and not content for classrooms.” A photo of the sign can be found below. Half-Priced Books, the City of Wylie’s public library, McMillan Junior High, Wylie East High School, and private individuals were among the groups who helped donate more than 1,000 books for the event’s decor.

Additionally, with the exception of high school students who performed during a designated timeslot, the event was for adult attendees only. The book referenced has never been on a Wylie ISD shelf, and we are not sure what decorations at such an event have to do with Wylie ISD libraries or students.

Budget

Wylie ISD and the Board of Trustees are committed to being good stewards of tax dollars. The district will continue to make decisions that are in the best interest of students, staff and taxpayers while remaining transparent during the process. 

Dawn Shallow (01/23/23)

“Good evening. I am here tonight to want to be an informed taxpayer. I think I speak for all Wylie taxpayers. There’s 50,000 of us. I was reading the superintendent contract you approved nine weeks ago and I find it vague. So, in an effort for transparency, I would like some information posted on the website. When I’m reading the contract that you approved nine weeks ago, some of it’s straightforward… the base salary, $280,000, $6,000 for a car allowance, $12,000 for civic responsibilities, that brings us to $296,000 a year. But what I am confused about is vague and I would bet that not one single taxpayer knows the answer to this. Probably the eight of you do and maybe HR. The Texas retirement, this is kind of vague. It says the district shall supplement the superintendent’s salary by an amount equal to the superintendent’s portion of the monthly member contribution to the TRS for the term of the contract, including any extensions. This salary supplement shall include both the retirement and TRS-Care parts of the TRS member contribution. So my question to you is, and this is what I would like published, how much exactly is that? Because I go to the TRS and it says eight percent is the member contribution rate. So, is our superintendent getting paid the $296,000 in addition to the eight percent more, which would be another $22,000? I would bet not one single taxpayer knows the answer to this. Only you guys do. So I would like to know exactly how much we pay our superintendent. How much is the TRS retirement we pay for him and how much is the TRS health we pay for him? So I would like that for transparency because eight percent is another $22,000. So, I would just like to know the answer to that. I would like to say thank you, school board, for working for free. Thank you.”

Jeffrey Keech (10/24/22)

"Hi, I'd like to start by just thanking Mitch Herzog and Heather Leggett for your service as a trustee. My children and many others have benefited from all your service to this community. When I was about 11, I joined the Boy Scouts and I remember being asked one of the first things I was asked was, how do you eat an elephant? If anyone knows how to eat an elephant? Well, you eat it one bite at a time. So let's say that you know that we want to talk about this flattening the tax rate, what do you call it, no-new-revenue-rate or just keep the taxes next year what they are this year.

In order to do that, you have to start by looking for ways to save money. I'm sure there's at least some waste in a government entity with a $231 million budget. So I think a good place to start and maybe identify some line items in our budget that may not be necessary. Like I’ve seen expenses for $12,000 for T-shirts, $15,000 for a keynote speaker, $10,000 for a different keynote speaker. And I wonder if those are all necessary? Maybe they are. But I wonder if you've looked into those. Or maybe look at the travel budget between July of 21 and April of 22. The district spent about $86,000 on plane tickets, hotel expenses, travel agent fees and conference registrations. I'm sure if we add in the per diem, that total amount is well over $100,000. The district attended conferences in places like New Orleans, New York, Las Vegas and San Diego. In a post-COVID world, I wonder if those travels are really necessary. Then private sector companies all over the world are finding out that no, they're not necessary. In fact, you can probably learn as much or more by attending conferences virtually or taking online training classes. I do believe the district spent about 30 nights at the Kalahari Waterpark Resort in Round Rock. I wonder if that was necessary. I would imagine it’s very distracting there. And I think you could probably get the same amount of learning without having to travel there.

And while we're discussing some of the conferences, let's look at some of the material that was presented at one of these conferences. In the last two years, the ISD sent 13 counselors to the American School Counselors Association annual conference, the opening session for this conference talked about educational equity. There was a session about implementing culturally sustaining anti-racist practices in their work. There was a session about supporting transgender and gender-expansive students. I wonder first they had to define what a gender-expansive student is. And there was also a session that asked what does it mean to be white? One of the answers on the bullet point given was that because white folks don't necessarily see whiteness as a culture, this allows them to think about themselves as individuals and not white. And I don't think that kind of thinking has any place in this school district or any in the country." - Jeffrey Keech

Jessica Fourrier (10/24/22)

"For the past two years, I have been more involved coming to the board meetings, reading all the school emails and really trying to know what's going on with Wylie ISD. My family moved to Wylie because we were told and believed that Wylie was a good school and a conservative city. I believe that Wylie is a conservative city but I think that the Wylie ISD school board and Vinson have fallen short, in so many ways. They have bowed to the woke culture that is ruining schools across America. We should be teaching patriotism in school, how to be proud of our country, how it was founded and how far it's come. We should be teaching Americans to be united and not divided because of their differences. That is not happening, but I think it should and could with the right people making the decisions.

Since the people supporting your campaign the keyboard warriors are so interested in truth in fact, I thought I would share some facts.

Fact number one. You as a board with Vinson, hired Sara Wicht from the Southern Poverty Law Center, paid her $15,000 to come up with the program “Let's Talk” which was to facilitate conversations between teachers and students about white privilege, Black Lives Matter, mass incarceration and police brutality. You did this without consulting parents and ended up wasting taxpayer money.

Fact number two. At the Wylie High School graduation in 2020, Virdie Montgomery asked all students to kneel for solidarity for George Floyd and social injustice. And all of y'all knelt with him. Why on earth would you think that it's okay to teach children about a personal belief that you have my house would never kneel for a criminal that assaulted a pregnant woman, no matter how he died.

Fact number three. In January, I spoke at the board meeting about the books that are obscene in our schools and asked that they be reviewed. None of you emailed me. I asked Jacob Day to check into the book issue at the next meeting and he said he would. I never heard back from him. I've heard y'all say Wylie ISD doesn't have any bad books in their library. That's a lie. The bad books are not just about pornography, but also about CRT and books glorifying teen suicide. Wylie ISD has secretly removed at least six books on this list without communicating with me or posting it on the forum that y'all created to show your transparency.

Fact number four. Wylie ISD is not allowing parents to assist with the book review process, which by state law they're required to do. It does not matter if you yourself consider that you have an established library. That's not real.

Fact number five. I have emailed the entire board at least 15 times in the past two years and I've received either a generic thanks for your email or nothing at all. What does that say for your transparency?

Fact number six. You all claim to be conservative. Even though you say this is a nonpartisan race. Yet you all have voted on, done things that would not support your claim to being conservatives.

[Board President Stacie Smith interjects, “Mrs. Fourrier, please remember that there's no electioneering allowed, this will be your only warning.”]

Fact number seven. Please don't waste my time. I'm gonna keep going. You have been spreading misinformation to the public about the taxes. The tax rate y'all voted on was technically numerically lower than last year. But because of house prices going up so much, you will be getting 11% more from the citizens of Wylie, totaling $16.8 million more dollars than last year. And you knew what the mortgage rates were before you voted. So in essence, you did raise taxes. So in conclusion, you're not transparent. You don't work with parents unless they're patting you on the back and you're not conservative. I will not be voting for you." - Jessica Fourrier

Jill Palmer (10/24/22)

"Good evening. First, I want to begin by saying thank you to Heather Leggett and Mitch Herzog, because I know, I understand this is a thankless position. And I know it's hard to be under a microscope constantly, especially when your integrity and character are always in question. I think we all can say we're having issues understanding and, you know, navigating when your integrity and character is being questioned.

So let's talk about that real quick. There was a blanket statement that has been made that there are no bad books in this district. Why then do I have 226 books listed in this document of books are currently in Wylie High or East. Out of those 226, 35 of those were at Cooper, and out of those 226, six have actually been removed.

Which is kind of odd because I know there's a system in place. According to EF local that a parent should be able to submit a form, apparently, in order to get a book removed. Well I know none of the concerned parents have done that. But now, from March 22 to now, six books have been removed, which is great. It's a great step in the right direction. But the fact is, six books actually have been removed, yet my integrity and my character and being called a book burner. Why the secrecy of all this?

Let me just list out the books… “The Bluest Eye,” “Traffic,” “Tricks,” “Lawn Boy,” and the latest, “Me Earl and the Dying Girl” and “L8R, G8R.” These were in our schools, we have the receipts. We have the screenshots of them in our schools. And now as of today, at 5:15 when I checked, they are not there. So six have been removed by this administration. So you're basically proving our point. We came to you as a community with a valid concern. You did not acknowledge it, you actually pushed us aside, and you did it on your own. That's not standing with integrity or transparency or communicating with this district. The books were removed, we have the receipts, so just own it. That's all we want. Just say, ‘my bad, we were wrong and we did it.’ You're basically making our point valid. So in order for you to answer the question on the public forum site, did you or did you not remove the six books and I will list them again: “The Bluest Eye,” “Traffic,” “Tricks,” “Lawn Boy,” “Me Earl and the Dying Girl” and “L8R, G8R.”

And please be honest, don't manipulate your answer based on whatever training you were given by our taxpayers to pay for the Marguiles Group and answer in truth and honesty and with integrity." - Jill Palmer

Michael Schwerin (10/24/22)

"Thank you. I would also like to start by thanking Heather and Mitch and all the rest of you all for your support and for your tireless work. As others have said that is, it’s a thankless job. And as we continue to learn over the last several months, that it is truly challenging when your character and your integrity is constantly attacked. So I want to thank you all for your service, especially Heather and Mitch, since y'all are retiring this year. So thank you.

I do also want to talk a little bit about facts, though, since that sounds to be really something that's important in our community right now, which I think it is. It really is important. I think one of the things that's important to be a factual thing to talk about is that no one, I don't think there's a single teacher, a single person that's spoken at a board meeting last two years, objects to the greatness of Wylie ISD. We all moved here for that reason, most of us if we weren't born here and raised here, we'd moved here for that reason. It is a destination district. And no one denies that our teachers are some of the best teachers in the state, and administrators are the best administrators in the state. I think we've all agreed upon that. I think we can all also agree that when you are great, you should also be focusing on what you can do to become better. And you should always be focusing on what you can do to be better. You always have that grit to improve yourself and always look about the people coming up behind you, the districts coming up behind us that are trying to get better than we are. And so I think on that mindset, we need to look at the facts of what's happened over the last two years. And looking at what has happened whether it was two years ago with the start of the diversity and inclusion program.

It was started in a lot of hindsight or a lot of hidden areas that we didn't know when we hired a consultant, as was mentioned earlier, that we didn't know about, that was fairly radical. And even when we came out, and when parents came out and spoke in April of that year, it took six more months before you all decide to put it on an agenda to have that conversation. But there was no discussion about it. It was just a simple report, and no actual questions about what we should do and should we actually have this in our district. And now it's kind of slowly disappeared and gone by the wayside with no D&I director or not really much movement since the pillar meetings last year. So I think it's at least we're grateful that we've put that forward. And we as parents have helped improve our district in that way.

Another thing that’s been raised up is the books. And I do hope as Jill and others have said that I guess I pray for you all to be careful and be mindful because you're probably going to call book burners, book Nazis, as we have, as we bought up and discuss this because you all have removed six books from the library. There are almost 200 more that you need to remove. So let's keep on going. And I think the last thing, again, is taxes. You can reduce taxes. Yes, it's gonna be hard, yes it’s going to be complicated, but you can and you choose not to. Thank you." - Michael Schwerin

Dawn Shallow (09/19/22)

“Tonight I'd like to talk about numbers. The first number is the number four. That number four is the number of years that you've served on the school board. This is also the number of years since you held your hand and took your oath of office. I want to talk about budget numbers. When you took your office four years ago, the Wylie budget was $172,563,585. You increased the budget in 2019 $20 million. You increased the budget in 2020 $5.4 million. Reasonable. You increased the budget in 2021 $16.7 million, and you increased the budget in 2022 $16.7 million. That is an addition to the $190 million bond package.

Today, four years later, our budget is $231,480,148. In the last four years since you've been in office, the budget has increased $58,916,563. That's a budget increase over four years of 34.14%. Let's talk about student enrollment numbers. These are based on the number you provided to the TEA. Four years ago, when you took office, we had 16,459 students enrolled. In 2019, that increased 703. In 2020 that increased 258, and in 2021, that increase 735. And in 2022, increased 581. So today, after four years in office, we now have 18,736 students enrolled. In four years, that's an increase of 2277 students or an increase of 13.31%.

So let's review those numbers again, Wylie ISD budget increased 34.14% in four years, student enrollment increased 13.83% in four years. Here's another number point .0000001, as in one cent, think in terms of cents, that's exactly the number you kept the budget under so that you didn't have to call for a public election. You increase our budget $16.7 million. If you had raised it one more cent, we the public would have got to vote on that. But the final two numbers I have are 35 and 50. 35 represents the number of days until early election on October 24. And 50 represents the number of days until the election on November 8. Thank you.” -Dawn Shallow

Michael Schwerin (09/19/22)

“Thank you. I come tonight as I do on most nights speaking as a parent, as a parent of a special needs child. And in the mindset of asking you why you're not continuing to support the special ed department. Having talked with many parents, paraprofessionals, and teachers in the special ed department over the last several months, I've actually learned that there are deficiencies in this department. While at the board meeting last month, you decided to spend lots of time asking absurd questions about paper clips and markers and whether or not we have enough money to buy paper clips and markers. And not actually talking about things that matter like the special ed department and ensuring that our special needs students are cared for and honored.

I also come speaking as parents that are too afraid to come and talk and speak here tonight. Out of fear and intimidation by the school board and by this district. They don't want to be singled out online by a dubious page that's set up for people that are speaking here this evening. They're too worried about maybe misspeaking, as I did one night several months ago and accidentally said billions instead of millions, and then was called a liar. You know, you're too worried about that and making yourselves look good, rather than actually focusing on actually doing good things and want to actually try to be the best district in the state and be the first one to reach the no new revenue rate, instead of just saying, ‘no one else is doing it, so why should we?’ And I think it's really important to make sure that we're not being singled out. And not singling out and attacking parents, just because they may misspeak or they may disagree with you. I'm also speaking for all the teachers and paraprofessionals, and the staff in the community that I've run into over the coming cut last several months that feel they can't say what they want to say, for fear of losing their job or their position. That's a scary place to be in. As a nonprofit executive who has managed a team, I would never want any one of my team members to feel scared to say something because they might lose their job. And that should be a shame on all of you for allowing that kind of fear and intimidation to be out there and to be here. You shouldn't be maybe more focusing on making yourselves look good and actually focus on why that's happening, why so many teachers are leaving this district the last couple of years, the numbers have skyrocketed. I'm not going to give the exact number because I might misquote myself and then I'll probably be called a liar tomorrow. And I'm also speaking for all the children in the district. All those that come from families who are struggling to make ends meet, the families I meet on a daily basis who are struggling to decide whether they put food on their table or pay their tax bill or pay their rent or pay for utilities. Those are the people that are hit the hardest by your choices in spending and choosing to overspend. They're the ones that have to make those tough decisions and have to look at moving out of the district because they can't afford it as even some actual staff members of Wylie ISD have told us that they had to move out.” -Michael Schwerin

Kevin Brooks (09/19/22)

“Madam President, members of the board. My reason for being here tonight is simple. The system is broken. It is broken and it lies in a state of disrepair and has been for quite some time. The reason it is in disrepair is because you have abdicated your responsibility to be the watchman on the wall. Your responsibility to be the wall that protects our most precious commodity, our children. You have failed. You have failed our children. You have failed our schools. You have failed our educators and you have failed our community. You are not accessible to the electorate. You do not return phone calls. You do not return emails. Yet you raise taxes every year, even this year, to the point to where it would not have to trigger an election, just short to where we the people would have to vote on the increase. People are leaving Wylie ISD for cheaper and sometimes greener pastures and that should not be. You are the masters of misinformation when you continually and repeatedly state Wylie ISD is subject to recapture also known as Robin Hood when we are not. You treat the electorate with what can best be described as disdain and as a nuisance if we are not in agreement with your plans and policies. The electorate sets the vision for the district and votes in the board that supports the direction they want for the district. The board takes that vision to the superintendent for implementation within predetermined parameters and budgeting. The relationship between the electorate, faculty, staff and administration, and the board should be one of an alliance and not an adversarial one, one where the faculty and staff and electorate are silenced and held hostage by the administration and the board. One where they're having to teach political correctness of what we see in societal decline on display 24/7 on television, and the web with no say in the matter. Both current and former educators have zero confidence in the board. We the people assure them that that will change. Being labeled as fascist, book burners, book banners and red shirts we proudly wear we the people. Whereas on your shirt, you state only your names, playing to see your primary focus looks back at you from the mirror, but it's all about the kids. In closing, you're all a disappointment, but that can be fixed, that needs to change, and that will change, if you vote. Thank you.” -Kevin Brooks

According to our records, Mr. Kevin Brooks has never reached out to the Wylie ISD Board of Trustees President Mrs. Stacie Smith or Dr. David Vinson. The only current trustee Mr. Brooks has reached out to about a concern is Mr. Bill Howard. Mr. Howard pointed him to the campus principal and Assistant Superintendent for Student Services, Mr. Scott Winn. On a public website, Mr. Brooks stated, “After talking with Coach Howard I wrote a letter and sent it to Coach, Scott Winn and Beth Craighead. They were all awesome!”

The board and district administrators respond to emails, return phone calls and meet with stakeholders. We typically try to respond to emails or return calls within 24-48 hours. If a parent or community member has reached out to the district and not received a response, we request that they send a follow-up email. Additionally, while board members welcome emails from all stakeholders, oftentimes, questions or concerns are ones that can only be addressed by district staff. To ensure questions or concerns that are outside the board’s purview are addressed, board members will acknowledge the communication and then direct the superintendent to respond.

In rare occasions, the district has decided to cease communication with individuals due to repeated emails about the same topic or requests for answers to the same questions. Our first priority is ensuring that our students are safe, learning and thriving, and that our teachers and staff have the support they need to take care of our students. While responding to and communicating with stakeholders is very important, the district cannot continuously divert resources to respond to repetitive questions from a sole person.

Mr. Brooks is correct, our school district is not subject to recapture.

Randi Jackson (09/19/22)

“Good evening, I want to start off once again by saying a continued and genuine thank you for maintaining the parent's right to choose when it comes to medical freedom. And I want to just how we got here. There's a lot going on right now. And to those just now getting involved, it may come as a shock that there are those in our community that are unsatisfied with representation as parents, teachers, or taxpaying citizens. Now, we ended up hearing from a lot of different causes that piqued our interest over the years. For me personally, it was the struggle my special needs child went through and the regression both academically and socially from the mask mandates, which I know initially was not a district mandate, but others have similar stories, but with different issues that are close to their hearts. And notably, what has been very interesting and frustrating is that the more and more parents and citizens have been getting involved, seemed like the first knee-jerk reaction was to circle the wagons and limit our speaking time from five minutes to three minutes. Because either there wasn't a lot that you were hearing that you were liking, or simply following the lead of similar districts that were hearing from their constituency and weren't liking it. So, you know, that tendency to follow what others are doing is not from what I understand, leading as in the Wylie Way. Now, when we did start getting involved, we had gotten, you know, the idea and the impression that haven't gotten so not used to such a diverse community of involvement, the Board of Trustees and administration got used to doing their own thing and didn't seem too keen on being questioned. Being under tougher scrutiny seemingly led to what appears on the outside to be defensive behavior and dismissive attitudes towards those of us who refuse to stop pushing for transparency in our district. So that commonly perceived attitude is what has brought us to where we are today. It won't be easy going forward because the way things have been is no longer acceptable. It means that Wylie ISD needs to step up and it's going to take change. It's going to take determination, and it's really going to take courageous leadership. Thank you for your time.” - Randi Jackson

Jill Palmer (09/19/22)

“Good evening. I want to begin by saying thank you, President Smith, from the last board meeting, I think it was really great to pull a consent agenda item forward after you saw or you heard public comments. I think it's really great to have real-time engagement, which is very important. It kind of builds on the transparency. With that being said, I'm going to piggyback on what I spoke about last month, I kind of explained about two items that the community that was involved and was part of the solution came together with the D&I pillars to figure out some action points that we want to see for 22-23. I did reach out asking for those TNA to figure out what's going on. Still don't have them. And we're like, what month two and that started the school year? We have no TNA on those initiatives. But I'm starting to connect the dots because it seems from multiple insiders in this district have basically confirmed that the D&I program no longer exists. Whether that's true or not, I do not know. But that's the communication that's coming from inside your district. So if that's the case, what were we doing last year? What was the point of those pillar meetings? If you want to shy from controversy and not speak out, and actually implement the communication of what that program means going forward? Like, what are we doing? So I'm gonna leave you with a question and two follow-ups. One, does the D&I program exist? Yes or no? Follow-up two. If it doesn't, where did that funding go? Where did it get reallocated? And three, if it got rebranded, got put under a different umbrella… is it Title IX? Because according to state legislature, once a designator of the Title IX coordinator title is designated, the district must notify applicants for admission and employment, students, parents and legal guardians, employees, and professional organizations holding professional agreements with this district of the name of the said coordinator. We haven't received any confirmation of what that means for Wylie ISD. So for those of you watching online who see just a red shirter, who are not listening to the question I'm asking that brought on a culture war in this community, does the D&I program actually exist? I'll leave it to you to answer.” - Jill Palmer

Jarrett Erwin (08/15/22)

“According to the Texas Comptroller's Office, the combined school tax rate for those residing in Wylie ISD is in the top 5% of tax rates out of over the 1550 public schools in Texas. I was unable to attend the recent budget workshop meeting on May 16 but watched the recorded posting online and was very disappointed. I want to encourage every Wylie ISD taxpayer to watch this recording to form your own opinion. It was disappointing that several elected trustees seemingly showed how little they actually know about the budget and the tax rate. The school board themselves is not actually saving the taxpayers 6 cents, just 2 months ago the school board committed to an 18% increase which was later adjusted to an 11% increase only because property values were about half a billion less than anticipated. Please stop portraying that you cut the tax rate to save us money.”

“Additionally, Wylie ISD is not one of the 150+ schools in Texas that are subject to recapture which means we do not send our local tax dollars to the state to fund other schools. As stated in the budget workshop by the presenter, Wylie ISD is headed in that direction but would require a vote by the taxpayers to be implemented.”

“There are millions of dollars of our tax money that our elected trustees are responsible for and it seems some of our trustees don’t know the basics of our taxes and where our money is even spent. I recognize that this is a complex issue but how is that possible? I believe it's possible because our trustees aren’t involved in the process of setting the budget and tax rates which is a primary purpose of the job they were elected to do. I’m disappointed in the deception of the administration with a perceived goal of confusing the trustees and the public. Again, I encourage everyone to watch the May 16 board workshop recording. This is our local government. Where is the accountability for this wasteful spending? There doesn’t seem to be any. Wylie ISD taxpayers and voters want more and we deserve more, we want fiscal sanity restored within Wylie ISD and make no mistake this can be done without cutting teacher pay.” - Jarrett Erwin

Wylie ISD is heading into 2022-23 with a lower tax rate for the fourth consecutive year and a balanced budget, while still providing employees a raise and accommodating for the expected student population growth. It’s also important to note that 84 percent of the district’s budget is for payroll expenses, with 60 percent going directly toward those in the classroom.

Wylie ISD school board members are very involved in the budget process and understand the complexities of school finance. Trustees are also longtime homeowners in the district and are committed to being fiscally responsible with taxpayer dollars. Wylie ISD and several other Collin County school districts have higher tax rates than other districts across the state due largely to rapid student population growth. Collin County districts such as Prosper, Community, Princeton, Anna, and Royse City set higher tax rates than Wylie ISD in 2021. For the full list from the Texas Comptroller’s Officer of the 1,015 school districts, please visit the comptroller's website. Note: 1,550 are listed due to school districts spanning multiple counties.

Wylie ISD and other Collin County school districts are growing at a rapid pace while other districts are maturing and losing enrollment.

Trustees and the district are proud to offer an exemplary educational experience to students while remaining good stewards of taxpayer dollars. In fact, in the 2022 Texas Education Agency accountability ratings, Wylie ISD and each of its 20 campuses received an ‘A’ rating – Wylie ISD is the only school district in Texas with more than 10,000 students to have the district and all campuses earn an ‘A.’

Additionally, preliminary reports show that Wylie ISD will receive an ‘A’ in TEA’s 2021-22 School Financial Integrity Rating System of Texas (FIRST) ratings. What are FIRST ratings? From TEA: “The state's school financial accountability rating system ensures that Texas public schools are held accountable for the quality of their financial management practices and that they improve these practices. The system is designed to encourage Texas public schools to better manage their financial resources to provide the maximum allocation possible for direct instructional purposes.”

Recapture

Regarding recapture, Wylie ISD is not yet subject to recapture or what the public may know better as “Robin Hood.” What is recapture?

“Chapter 41, Education Code, was repealed. House Bill 3 amended the Education Code to transfer certain sections from Chapter 41 to Chapter 49, and revised formulas used to determine excess local revenue under the FSP by adding Subchapter F, Chapter 48, Education Code, Section 48.257, Local Revenue in Excess of Entitlement. This section of the Texas Education Code (TEC) makes provisions for certain school districts to share their local tax revenue with other school districts. These provisions are sometimes referred to as ‘share the wealth’ or ‘Robin Hood’ plan because recaptured funds are redistributed by the school finance system to assist with the financing of public education for all school districts.”

Wylie ISD anticipates being named a recapture district in the years to come. Mr. Jarrett Erwin is correct. A vote by taxpayers is required to decide how recapture fees are paid. However, should the vote not pass, the State of Texas would detach properties from the school district, reducing property values to ensure the district would not be subject to recapture. The detached properties would be reassigned to another school district and those property owners would be taxed at that district’s rate. Additionally, students living in those areas would go to school in the new district. Under current law, these properties would be permanently detached. The biggest concern of losing such properties would be a possible increase on the interest and sinking tax rate.

Kevin Brooks (08/15/22)

“Like many parents, I absolutely fell in love with Wylie ISD. My wife and son came from Brazil and I knew Dallas ISD was not for me and I moved immediately to Richardson ISD, followed quickly by a move to Wylie ISD. Also, like many parents, I left the politics and the admin stuff to the professionals. We entrusted people like you to do the right thing and what is best for our kids. That has turned out to be one of the worst decisions I have ever made. My 12-year-old daughter has been harassed about the colors she wears and being told that she must be LGBTQ. She was so upset about it, she came to me and I asked what she should do and asked me what she should do. I told her not to worry and daddy would take care of it. And I proceeded to make another mistake by trusting a school counselor to handle it by speaking to my daughter. He called me and tried to explain to me that we need to be accepting of all kids’ choices and I cut him off and I stated, ‘what you need to do is be the adult. You need to tell that young lady that’s giving my daughter a hard time that those meetings start at 3:31 because my daughter leaves at 3:30. And that the LGBTQ stuff is for after school, not during school.’ Well, nothing has changed. In fact, I began to look into it as I discovered even more discrepancies and feelings and the goings on in and around Wylie ISD. I do not have time to address them all here, but I will address a few. There is a principal that said it takes a village to raise a child. No sir. Stay out of my kids’ lives and focus on educating children. Please leave your social commentary and your social media accounts and me and my 12-year-old alone. I did not ask you to indoctrinate my kids to become social justice warriors. You were hired to teach. So teach. Reading, writing, arithmetic, science and civics.

There are sexual activities in the bathrooms, according to people that I’ve spoken to. Drug use, girls sitting ‘cooch to cooch’ in the hallways. Teachers I have spoken to that state they do not have the support of the administration and know these things, but say nothing because of fear of their jobs.” - Kevin Brooks

Mitch Fourrier (08/15/22)

“I sent all of you, plus several on my left and my right an email on January 28. Twelve of you total about Granbury ISD removing 125 books for review. I sent you a color-coded book list explaining GISD’s reason for review of the removal of the books. I received, out of the 12 that I emailed, I received one reply that was from Ms. Spicer that said you guys were looking into it. After several months with no response about the book list, after one of these meetings I spoke to Mr. Day, and kind of made him aware of it. He said he’d look into it. Again, I got no response. This issue has been brought up numerous times in these meetings to you just like I’m standing now by concerned parents, again no response.

About a week ago I searched the online library for both high schools and found that almost 100 inappropriate books were still there. One book from the GISD list was removed, but the rest weren't. Some books not on the GISD list were found in the LGBTQ section of the online library. On top of that, new books are still being added. Two of which I saw “She Gets the Girl” by Alyson Derrick and Rachael Lippincott and “All My Rage” by Sabaa Tahir. So some questions, what did you find while you were looking into it? Why haven’t you been transparent with what you have or haven’t found? Why is there an LGBTQ section of the library?

You should be neutral, not pushing an agenda. I asked you in the initial email and I'll ask you again. I asked you what the Wylie Way meant to you. Because that’s a phrase that you all put out there. Is this the Wylie Way? I expect more from all of you.” - Mitch Fourrier

Jeffrey Keech (08/15/22)

“School enrollment was 13,360 kids in 2012 that increased to 18,650 in 2022, that’s an increase enrollment increase of 5,200 students or 39 percent. The Wylie ISD budget increased from $117 million in 2012 to $231 million in 2022. That’s an increase of $113 million or 96 percent. So in summary, in the past 10 years, student enrollment has increased by 39 percent and the school budget has increased by 96 percent, more than double. Of course, when discussing budgets over multiple years you have to consider inflation rates, so according to the inflation rate, taken directly from the Bureau of Labor Statistics website, for those years I mentioned, it [inflation] ranged from .8 percent in 2014 to 7 percent in 2021. So the cumulative inflation rate for those years was 23 percent plus the 2022 rate. So I don’t because we don’t have the finished rates for 2022 I’m just gonna focus on the years from 2012-2021. Student enrollment in those years increased by 35 percent. The budget increased by 82 percent. So if this school district was limiting the budget increases to the rate of inflation plus student population growth which is a very fair way to do budgeting. The cumulative budget increase from 2012-2021 would have been 35 percent growth plus 23 percent inflation rate or 58 percent. That equates to a budget of $186 million for the 2021-22 school year. In actuality, the budget went up 82 percent to $214 million. So the difference between a 58 percent increase and an 82 percent increase is $28 million. According to the US Census Bureau, there were 15,730 households in Wylie in 2020 an increase of 530 from the year before, so if you extrapolate that to 2021 that’s roughly an estimated 16,260 households in Wylie in 2021. What that means is that from 2012-2021, the school budget grew to be above the enrollment plus inflation rate by $1,755 per household. Meaning every household in Wylie that pays taxes is paying an additional $1,755 because the budget has been out of control for that entire period of time.” - Jeffrey Keech

Michael Schwerin (08/15/22)

“Now I understand the proper roles of a board of directors, which is similar to a board of trustees and staff or administration. In these instances, the board, you all seven elected officials are the ones that set policy. And the staff is there to implement that policy. You all also give the budget guidance and the staff implements the budget and creates the budget based on that guidance. Of course, this is all involving staff in staff involvement in those processes but you seven are the ones that make those decisions and I still can’t understand why the seven of you have decided to abdicate that decision and give it all to the staff administration.

In fact, when I asked at the beginning of the year, calendar year, I reached out to each of you about setting the no new revenue rate, effective tax rate. I received things like, ‘money is given to the state and it’s not, it’s not all returned.’ Which wasn’t true. It’s really confusing. We need to rely on our staff. If, and then there was also the implication that it was because staff, because property values were rising, was why our taxes were going up, which again was not true. After being told multiple times that it was really confusing and really difficult, I went to work studying. I learned. I listened. I talked to others. Things that I wish that you all would of done. Cause I noticed there were no questions from you all about reducing spending from you, since January when the budget process started. No discussion about are these costs accurate and should they be done when we’re looking at the economic situation that we’re in when people are seeing their rents doubled because of inflation, because of the property taxes that you all are presenting to them. Why not? Why are you, instead of doing that, you’re complaining and calling us, calling those who are asking questions terrorists or red shirts instead of actually doing your job and doing your hard work?” - Michael Schwerin

Aleksandra Rolfson (08/15/22)

“One of the items on the agenda is interlocal cooperation agreement for governmental services for the I guess overtime pay for our SROs, I have no problem with that, that Wylie ISD is going to be sharing overtime pay with the city of Wylie. However I do have a problem that if you look at the whole document which is supposed to be filed with the county, I assuming is supposed to be filed with the county, and the bottom is for a person to sign it, and it has the city manager and the city manager is listed as Chris Holstead. He hasn’t been our city manager for a while. So don’t tell me you gonna be voting a-p with the city manager that’s now no longer there because this document isn’t getting amended.  Another thing on the agenda is item H request to change regular school board meeting dates. Your subject line has October, November, December, January and February due to the student holidays. If you go and look through the agenda packet, November is left out, so you have conflicting information. You have in the subject line October, November, December, January and February and more detail, but November is not there. So is this how our administration is writing this, I mean come on.. if nothing else you’re educators all of you. You can at least get the months straight and in one paragraph or four lines. I would appreciate it if you look through this consent agenda and make sure we don’t file wrong documents with the county and open ourselves to a lawsuit.” - Aleksandra Rolfson

Jill Palmer (08/15/22)

“This proud, red shirter’s question for you to add to the website so you can answer. What is your plan for executing the two most important action points from our DE&I meeting [creating training for district administrators on being consistent on how we address and execute and follow up on discipline issues so that we have consistency across the district. Creating a plan for how we can communicate our discipline reporting policies and procedures and what the process looks like from reporting to investigations to the follow-up with affected students, staff and families], that should of already been put into place, and it’s day three of the new school year and nothing has been done. That is the only answer I'm going to accept on its website.” - Jill Palmer

Randi Jackson (08/15/22)

"According to the Wylie ISD organizational structure, the top of the chart says students, parents and community members of Wylie, then the board of trustees, and then the superintendent of schools. In reality, it seems to operate in the exact opposite fashion. From what I personally have witnessed the superintendent provides the vision and the board rubberstamps the agenda with only cursory questions that are superficial and refuse to openly discuss options in a manner that includes and informs the public. Over one hundred unanimous votes in a row. On everything from tax rates and budgets to controversial programs and supplies. While the majority of consent items are standard like employee contracts and reports, that doesn’t mean that there shouldn’t be open and transparent discussion of the necessity for each item. From the perspective of parents and the community of Wylie, our concerns and inquiries are little more than an irritating inconvenience to the real top of the chart. And the board of trustees seems to feel stuck in the middle. What we need is courageous leadership, what we need is a board of trustees that understands that they're elected by the community of Wylie to set the vision for the district. And that it is the duty of the superintendent and their administration to bring that vision to fruition. When I started attending these board meetings, I had the highest hopes of the leadership of the board would shine through. And instead, I have felt like an unwanted intruder of the status quo. The way things are, the way things have been, we go by the policy with a refusal and actually an ardent disinterest in changing that policy, that you have the power to change, isn’t good enough as an answer anymore. Following policy isn’t good enough, following what other districts do isn’t good enough, following the primrose path toward the corruption of our education system isn’t good enough." - Randi Jackson